William Gattis
William Gattis - On discrimination (clip)
William Gattis (WG): We call that urban renewal. You see, so when we look up and if we really want to be realistic, they are synonymous in terms of the outcome, you see. So what I’m suggesting, as a kid, even if I’m young in the late 40s and the 50s, I’m still relegated to a place, you see. As a child, I don’t have the intellectual resources to understand what’s happening, but I do know there are places in the community I can’t go. I do see fountains that say “For Colored Only.” I do see places like Sears where you can’t put on the clothes in the store because of who you are and your background, you see. I see around me, as a child, I’m living in a part of the community where I only see who we are and what we are about. You see, so now, as a kid, I neither have the experience or the vocabulary to put this in the place, but I do know there are places that I can’t go. I do know that after sundown I need to be at home and it’s because my momma knows that if I’m outside of her care that I could be hurt by people, as we have suggested already Courtney, who come into the Black community and create pain for people just because they can do it and there’s no… I don’t have any resources to make sure that they pay for what they are doing, you see.
William Gattis - On gentrification (clip)
William Gattis (WG): We talk about the land being deeded for the [Hargraves] Center but it actually began with people like, I think, someone named Mr. Cole and someone by the name of Hackney. I can find out the information from Burnis Hackney. But in the early part of the community, they were community leaders who thought about a place. The background was that Black people did not have any place to go for recreation. We can trace it back as far back as I guess, 1937. Chapel Hill Newspaper would have something about that time. This area was referred to, like so many others, as areas that were worse than some of the ghetto places in New York City and that was a condition that we found ourselves in. You’ve already mentioned those things about not having proper town services. It was almost like it was an inconvenience of the Town to serve the Black community. So, Black children were getting into trouble so Hargraves Center became a place, at that time Roberson Street Center, a place that could be created so that kids would have a place to go and to stay off the streets and out of trouble. So, that was beginning. You get the beginning of Roberson Street Center being built but they didn’t have all of the funds to complete it. So, when the Naval people came in [during World War Two] and had no place to stay, there was an agreement that they would complete the basement, so that they would have quarters to live because they weren’t allowed to live in areas other than Hargraves in the town. So, that’s how you get the basis. Now you all have mentioned something that I wasn’t quite aware of because I thought the Center was named with regards to the name of the street. I never knew where the street name Roberson came from. And then now we have Mr. Hubert whose last name, and I had not made that connection as part of the history. But those were those rudimentary beginnings of the Center itself to have a place where we could go and not really get into trouble because a lot of kids would be getting into trouble in the town and, because of the situation at that time, it didn’t turn out very good for them nor their parents. So, that’s how we get the rudimentary beginnings of Hargraves Center. And I think the thing that’s connected to Mr. Peerman was the thing with the pool itself, when they were able to hire people who weren’t Black to be lifeguards and it was like a kind of integration of the pool. And that time, and Kathryn, I might have gotten a little bit ahead of myself. But anyway, that was part of the early history. The conditions that were worse than any, being relegated to an area that was really not viable for parents or their children and then forced to live in those conditions and you become an inconvenience for the whole town of Carrboro and Chapel Hill by existing. So, through that, from those backgrounds, you get people who are resourceful and brilliant and have visions about what a community should be and that’s where we get the rudimentary beginnings of Hargraves Center and all those things that make us as we move forward. What we are and the possibilities and we talk about gentrification but it was actually, when it comes down to it, came up with a CER Community [] Removal. And that’s where we are now when you get to… you have gentrification that starts out that you actually.
Rudy Jackson (RJ): You talk about gentrification, about when did that start?
WG: Well, let’s say it’s in the works but you actually get it coming to the forefront during the late 50’s and early 60’s.
Kathryn Wall: Already in the 60’s?
WG: You see because when you get it relegated you don’t have nice words, and then they come up with a nice word for it and it’s gentrification when you are actually being removed. But if I come into this community and I buy a house and I’m renting this house now I am what you call now property managers. Let’s just say we are at the time we are now. So, I’m a property manager so what I do is, I buy a house in the Black community because it’s affordable for me now and I rent it to white people and I rent it at a rate that you can’t afford to rent. You see, so you are being slowly removed from the community that you grew up in because, not only can you not afford the rent for the house but you live there now. Say if it was your house. You can’t even live in the house you grew up in because somebody has bought it and increased the rent…
RJ: You say that this occurred during the 50s? I saw that later.
WG: No, the whole idea is…What I’m suggesting here is it was occurring all along and at the point of the matter when we are being born. When we become more sensitive to the things that are going on around us, then our eyes are opened and we begin to see it. Now we may see it in the 50s depending on our age, we may see it in the 60s depending on our age, but it’s been happening all along. We’ve been relegated to the area all along. It didn’t just happen you see. So, this has been happening. So, now I’ve got a house and I’m renting it to white people at a rate that you can’t afford to live in this house. And, slowly, because you don’t have a place to stay or a job that can afford that kind of rent, you are being edged out. And those people who can afford it, who in my experience have been white, and then you get the influx, not because of their fault but because they have the resources to do it and I don’t. You see, so now we get to affordable places to live. Why? Because now I have to have the money to afford a place to live although I grew up in this community. So that’s just an aside y’all about how we get to Hargraves and the backdrop for it.
William Gattis - On his childhood on his family's farm, faith, education, and his time in the Air Force
William Gattis - On how lines were drawn (clip)
William Gattis (WG): Now, the date that we are talking about is around 1851…
Dr. Courtney Rivard: Yeah, let’s see if we can get a better timeline than what we have here.
WG: ... and the reason why I am saying that is that this is when these lines were drawn. It is even documented. Merritt Mill Road separated the two. That’s why McCauley Street does not touch Merritt Mill Road.
Pat Jackson: Right.
William Gattis - How far we have come (clip)
William Gattis: And it did not stop in the ‘50s. We experienced–we are still experiencing part of the fallout, but this went on through the ‘60s. The students from Lincoln High School, this was beginning in 1962 through ‘64, we’re talking about teenagers. And it has also been said that unfortunately, we were taught to respect adults, and unfortunately, you’re respecting the very people who are oppressing you. Why? Because it’s part of your home training. And this has just been an unfortunate thing but–an unfortunate representation of who we are and from how far we have come.
William Gattis - On violence (clip)
William Gattis: White men thought it was their point of duty to cross over into Northside or Pottersfield to rape Black women and kill Black men and then go back to the other side of town and not have to pay a price for that balance. And that is why, as we move along, parents would tell us: “There are certain places after dusk [where] you need to be at home” – because of the violence that these students would perpetrate with no reprisals from anybody.
William Gattis - On segregation and boundaries (clip)
William Gattis: If we historically want to find out, and this is my understanding: it was Northside with the adopted name Potter’s Field, because in the Bible, Potter’s Field was where we had the dead bodies. And the whole idea is we can’t have you all among us, so we’re going to put you on the outskirts. So, if we look at the original town and the layout, this is like the outskirts of the town. So then the Black people get sandwiched between Columbia Street and the railroad tracks in Carrboro. And where we are now, the haircut place, Midway, this is Midway.
William Gattis - Not the best place (clip)
William Gattis: And we talk about these people as though they were trained university workers. No, if the university is the big employer, it’s not only the biggest employer of Black people but white people as well. It is the emerald place, the invisible kingdom, and it is part of the structure, the segregated structure that relegated people of color to these areas. And these weren’t the best places, they were like, ghettos. And this makes it sound like, “Oh baby this is the best place to be in the world” you see. No not for Black people.
William Gattis - On your own narrative (clip)
William Gattis: But the upshot of the whole thing is that you get to write your own narrative and that’s why you have the walls. And I mentioned this before. You have Windy Hill is a wall of your house. Northside is a wall of your house, or Potter’s Field. Tin Top is one of the sides of your house. South Lane is another side of your house. Pine Knolls is another side of your house. But in that house, you get to write the narratives. And you are professionals, you’re teachers, you’re stone masons, you’re laborers, you have your own homes to grow into in a community and see people who are professionals with their own homes. A Black Wall Street.
Patricia "Pat" Jackson and William Gattis - On the cement pile (clip)
Kathy Atwater (KA): And, now it’s gone. No more Windy Hill,
Pat Jackson (PJ): No more Windy Hill.
KA: All the Black neighborhoods are gone.
William Gattis (WG): And we didn’t even get to Columbia Street because Church Street was a street that separated us–on one side White and on the other side Black and when you go down towards Tin Top after you get past what we call Ready Mix now, that was South Lane. It actually went that way and went right over back to Merritt Mill Road where they have the Southern Electric, something like that.
PJ: But remember you are calling it Ready Mix but remember it was the Cement Pile.
WG: Right, well it was Mule Head initially.
PJ: Yeah.
William Gattis - On segregated community (clip)
William Gattis: And what we have to understand [is] that during this time we have embraced – we have embellished – we have been complicit – in relegating people to a certain area, [and] making sure that they didn’t have the right tools to live. Now, if you can call 25 dollars a week–maybe– as an income, to have your own land and houses… Pretty much, those individuals that were relegated to these areas were self-sufficient, and visionary enough to create their own space and their own narrative. Because no town services were in these areas – nothing that has to do with a quality of life, was not part of this area. These were people who were expendable, and that’s putting it lightly. So the initial premise that this story is based on is false – so everything that follows it becomes false. Because it was not the lap of luxury for Black people.
William Gattis - On the loss of innocence (clip)
William Gattis: And as a kid, the other part to this puzzle is, and a lot of older people can attest to this, you actually learn as a child where you can go and be safe and not harmed. And you know at the bus station, you’re gonna go downstairs to use vending machines. And one of the sisters at St. Paul related her story of how she lived in Greenville, same thing, same scenario. The kids had to learn early. You talk about a loss of innocence? Imagine some of these places that you can go. The loss of innocence… a child in its own innocence, a child of color, is asking her father, “Daddy, why are we going to the back door when everybody else is going to the front? This is a child, so that becomes a loss of innocence. And like I said before it’s not even an elective, you are relegated to this kind of life in order to survive.
William Gattis - Reading the introduction (clip)
Patricia “Pat” Jackson: …now where is this place?
William Gattis: (Reading from the Wikipedia entry in italics) Pottersfield, also called Pottersville, was a large historically Black neighborhood located in downtown Chapel Hill–No way!–downtown Chapel Hill, North Carolina. It was originally built over a hundred years ago to be home for those working at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. These workers included the stonemasons– they constructed the famous stone walls encircling the university campus. And those that carried water from the old well to students in the dorm. And then we get to the 1950s. Well, no.
Dr. Courtney Rivard and William Gattis - On compassion (clip)
Courtney Rivard (CR): Mr. Gattis, you make me think about the ways in which a fear that I have about how knowledge is getting formed today, and in the future, right? If Wikipedia is gonna prevent us from using these direct experiences because it’s about secondary sources, well that’s fine, it’s an encyclopedia, that’s it’s genre, but if that’s being used as the data that’s going to be used to shape the knowledge when our children, my children, google something, that glossing is gonna be the dominant narrative, right? So, you are making me feel like this is more important than ever to kind of force it in there, right, so thank you.
William Gattis (WG): I think the word might be compassion. Even Dr. King said, “Our worth is not in being uncomfortable, the challenge comes when we have the uncertainty and the challenge is facing us.” You see, that’s where you prove…when it’s all good, yeah, you okay, and I have had people talk to me about “Oh, yes. I’m in. I know” but you’re comfortable, you are entitled, you have everything, you have the blessings, but when they are taken away, that is when you have the worth and proof of a person, when your future is uncertain and when there are challenges in front of you, how do you stand as an individual, as a person, as a group?
Patricia "Pat" Jackson and William Gattis - On Lincoln High (clip)
William Gattis (WG): We’re talking about 1966, because that’s when–well beginning around 1964 is when some of us began to enter the Chapel Hill High System.
Patricia “Pat” Jackson (PJ): This says Lincoln High School in 1962, and see Lincoln High School in 1962 was Lincoln High School. Didn’t have anything to do with Frank Porter Graham.
WG: Frank Porter Graham came much later when they were adding students.
PJ: Exactly.
WG: And so, yeah.
PJ: Yeah, When Dr. Frank Porter Graham was doing his research at the university and working to purchase land off of Merritt Mill Road for his research to work with students that were delayed with children, younger children. Yeah - didn’t have anything to do with Lincoln High.
Virginia Carson, Pat Jackson, and William Gattis - On Reconstruction (clip)
Virginia Carson (VC): Some piece of this also goes back to Reconstruction. The church archives at Chapel of the Cross, there were free people of color in Chapel Hill. Chapel Hill was a really small place and the University, but there were free people of color who were skilled workers of one kind or another and they lived along Franklin Street and Rosemary Street. The rigorous segregation came in after emancipation when all of sudden it was very important that people be separated, so there’s an interesting wrinkle, sort of, in the time progression from the early 1840’s until it gets really rigid after the war.
William Gattis (WG): Well, it became rigid because of the push back of the Klan and those of that same mind.
VC: Absolutely.
WG: Initially…
Pat Jackson: Which [the Klan] was alive and well in Carrboro.
William Gattis and Patricia "Pat" Jackson - Glossing over (clip)
William Gattis (WG): Unfortunately, Katherine, the whole premise on which it starts is wrong. For example, it gives a more modern-day version of what happened. If you can imagine the 1865 Emancipation Proclamation in the Chapel Hill Area. For example, this starts off as…
Patricia “Pat” Jackson (PJ): This Pottersfield is glamorous.
WG: Right
PJ: The Pottersfield that we knew was thrown away property that nobody else wanted that nothing else could happen on, and they said, “OK. You could use this area”.
WG: Actually it wasn't so much “you could use,” but “This is where you’re relegated to, because we have established Chapel Hill–white Chapel Hill–as being between Boundary Street and Merritt Mill Road. This is our territory. Now we’re going to relegate you all to the Northside or Pottersfield area, to Tin Top, to Pine Knolls, to South Lane, and Windy Hills. Because these are the worst areas in the town, and we aren’t going to be there but we don’t mind you all being there.” So this is a glamorous–in fact let me just read from it just a little bit.
PJ: It’s just so pretty I couldn’t stop reading it.
Alexandra Odum, William Gattis, and Patricia "Pat" Jackson - On sources (clip)
Alexandra Odum: The last question I have, when a lot of the original pages when they are written by students, they are looking at things like things like from the Rock Wall, They are looking at different digital newspapers, To some extent they are looking at historical resources, so I guess what are some of the sources that you think are most accurate in representing the history of different sites in the town of Chapel Hill.
Patricia "Pat" Jackson: Well, I would say in looking at the material that we are looking at tonight, it came from students that did research to find out things, but what they found out, they’ve glossed it as opposed to, I guess, what we know it actually was. You know, so, I don’t know…if this is a beautiful spin on it and it wasn’t so beautiful for us, I guess. So, that’s what I mean when I say they’ve got the information, read the information, they got it from somewhere, you know, just like you are saying but it’s glossed over to make it beautiful. And…
William Gattis: They are speaking from their perspective, you see, that’s how they write and what it does is it helps us find a starting point in which we can go back and tweak the information because they’ve actually gotten the information but we can tweak it.
William Gattis and Patricia "Pat" Jackson - On a timeline (clip)
Patricia “Pat” Jackson (PJ): So, do you have the time frame better?
Dr. Courtney Rivard (CR): So I have 1865-1870 when reconstruction began and then, and, I don’t know if this is too much time, 1865 to 1920, the birth of … the solidification of Jim Crow, then 1920 to 1950?
William Gattis (WG): If I had the timeframe, then I would say 1870 to the 1900’s, that’s when we get the Birth of a Nation and all that stuff that was also part of the pushback, and then you have us up to 1929 which was the crash and the point there is that we are surviving that period and then you have us, from say the crash in 1929 up to “the 50’s” or maybe around that time that OC (Orange County Training School) was started, but then around 1951 or so, somewhere between 1949 and ’51 we get Lincoln High School, you see.
CR: So, Lincoln High School is like a threshold moment
WG: Right definitely because then we are able to go higher in the education ladder and then from there to, I would say 1966, when we may have formally been going to Chapel Hill High out on Homestead. And then, of course, you’ve got that period into the 70’s and then I guess you could go decades.
CR: Like you could go 1980’s, 1990’s, 2000’s…
PJ: And in those 18 somethings, had to be, this is where our ancestors I guess were being kept by the White people in town because all of them are buried in the cemetery right at the end of campus. William Gattis: That’s why we can look at Wilson Caldwell, November Caldwell as timelines for that part because I think that it was Wilson that had the first school before we … down where Henderson Street is before we get to the Hackney School. But those names kind of frame that part of the time.
Virginia Carson (VC): Aren’t you glad you asked?
CR: I definitely, I have learned so much.
William Gattis and Patricia "Pat" Jackson - On neighborhoods (clip)
Alexandra Odom (AD): And so how far back would you go? I think, Mr. Gattis, you said something about 1850. What is the earliest that… and I know we are talking about reconstruction and we’re talking about 1855 and post-emancipation, so when we talk about Potters Field, where exactly should that story begin and where should the origins of that neighborhood begin? What should the starting point be?
Pat Jackson (PJ): Well, I guess we’ll have to do some research for the beginning because for us, what we know is the Orange County Training School because that’s where our parents went to school.
Kathy Atwater (KA): I want to ask this question. Maybe Pat and Mr. Gattis may know. When was the time that Blacks were on Franklin Street, because I was told that we were on Franklin Street but we were pushed off.
PJ: We were. That was during the 1920’s as well. Well, I guess 1932 because 1925 is when they were all, when we knew that they were all born and all of them were born over in just this area right here. Right here at the Church. Sunset. Windy Hill. All of them branched and that’s when all the businesses were on Rosemary and those businesses extended down Franklin Street. That’s when the apartments were down Franklin Street, half of us was living on Franklin Street.
William Gattis (WG): But notice it came from Columbia Street this way, so if you look at the birth of Miss Frances Neal Hargraves, their family lived right where the McDonalds is and along that street coming all the way up here we had housing like where JiffyLube and …
PJ: All of that. We all had apartments and houses that we all lived at. So, I guess we’ll have to check the Chapel Hill Historical Society to see when that changed–when we got moved to Potters Field which is now Northside.
WG: Right. We were… it was an all-encompassing thing because not all of us… Some were in Northside and some were at these other places, you see. So, it’s almost like it’s happening simultaneously and it’s almost like Potters Field/Northside become a name overlay for an area that you are already in, you see. And while it may look like where Sunset came later, Sunset was there just, for a thought process, all along. The streets were named: Nash/Sunset/Sykes. You see McDade/Lindsey/Mitchell. Now Mitchell Lane was there when Professor Mitchell was at the University because it’s named after him.
William Gattis and Dr. Courtney Rivard - On Windy Hill (clip)
Dr. Courtney Rivard (CR): May ask a question because I want to think how we are going to be able write this in the Wikipedia and I just want to start by saying thank you. Thank you.
Patricia “Pat” Jackson (PJ): Now shut up. [Laughter]
CR: No, actually just the opposite. There’s some translational work that’s gonna need to get done and I want to make sure we do it accurately. So, there’s two, several questions that I have. The first is like how could we define the boundaries of the area in a way that’s accurate.
William Gattis (WG): The way you do that is with the Historic Society. There is a map. It’s actually down at Lincoln School. The map that shows Merritt Mill Road as being the separator, okay. So, there is actually a map that defines the area and then if you look back and Richard Ellington could probably help you do that. If you look back to when the town was founded, you will also see the documentation for Boundary Street and Merritt Mill Road. And what we also have to understand is that we are looking at these places through modern eyes.
CR: Sure.
WG: In fact, at that time for example, going down that hill towards Estes Drive was just a muddy hill. So, Boundary Street is right before you get to where you are descending, you see, so you cut it off there. And in 1937, if you check the earlier Chapel Hill Weekly, said these areas are worse than ghettos in New York. So, we have the documentation in the Chapel Hill Weekly referring to that same time frame.
Dr. Courtney Rivard and William Gattis - On glossing over history (clip)
Courtney Rivard (CR): The point about glossing over is about teaching the students how to write a little more, with more intention. So, this is very helpful to hear especially Sara is getting ready to teach. I think that it might be useful to hear this and play it for your students in class. It’s a learning experience for me too. A lot of people criticize Wikipedia for glossing and a lot of people are now talking about these kind of AI- generated things that are occurring and the same gloss. So, it makes me think about how we can write on this page that does justice to what you have just said Mr. Gattis and the fights that we are likely going to have to have with the Wiki community.
William Gattis (WG): Well part of it is and to your point, people are doing it in a kind of innocent way but you can take a Negro spiritual and have the best voices, say Irish voices, and they can give you the best rendition of it, for example, “Lift Every Voice and Sing” but because–and it’s perfect, picture perfect, sung perfect–but because they lack the experience they don’t have that feeling for what it means. So, what we try to do as teachers and educators is, if I can get you close to the experience, perhaps you can understand, and this doesn’t just work in the Black experience but the White experience. Any kid who is going through an issue that I’m not familiar with, how can I be close enough to what you are telling me, so I can understand what you’ve going through, so from my experience, I can help you grow, you see. So, it’s a … I would say, I don’t always look upon it as a person of color thing because we are all affected by it, but as a nation, as a group, as a people, it affects all of us because we have to be able to understand in order to grow ourselves. Can I stand in your place? Even President Kennedy one time said “If you think the experience of Black people is so good, which one among you would take his or her place?” And, living in this time, with all of the benefits and blessings that we have, I may be the hope and dream of a slave and their potential but I wouldn’t want to go back to that experience, you see? Too painful for me to even think about it. Let alone to live it, you see?
William Gattis - On free people of color (clip)
William Gattis: I don’t know how you grade being hated, being enslaved. We get the Emancipation Proclamation. You get the 13th, 14th, 15th Amendment and then after the 1870’s is when you start getting the pushback against a lot of things. For example, you could be in Chapel Hill, maybe live in these areas, but there were Black-owned businesses on the other side of Franklin Street, you see, but these were people who had name recognition in the town. Very prominent. And when we are talking about free people, we aren’t talking about a lot of them and they didn’t live just in this area because there was a family out on what is now Martin Luther King that had families, had owned land, and made sure their children got educated out near Eubanks Road somewhere out in that area, but these are an exception rather than the rule, and it didn’t mean that they were totally free because you could actually have freed people of color, catched and taken further south and end up as a slave again. So, it wasn’t like you have total freedom but you were freed or you were born freed and you had that status, but it wasn’t like you were all that, you see, because of your color you could be taken at any time. And because I think people were relegated to these areas that I have named you had a way of protecting yourself, you see, because you were grouped together but you also, as I said before, you have a way of writing your own narrative and being your own people in spite of the segregation that surrounds you. But you still had to go out into that world and live because like in the initial presentation [] some of them were self-sufficient but it wasn’t like they were put out initially in the Potters Field area or those other areas in nice houses. They pretty much, because of their skills built their houses.
William Gattis - Lift Every Voice and Sing (clip)
William Gattis (WG): If you really want to know Black history, take the time to sometime read “Lift Every Voice and Sing.” Around 1910 it was written for children to tell them about their history. And if you go line for line, you will read about the struggle and I’m often surprised that even now we… if I had to start and I was teaching a history class, English class or whatever in the schools, and I wanted kids, all children to know about the history of people of color here, that’s where I would start because you can take each one of those paragraphs of lines and then go back and read the history that surrounded it. When you see a line like, “We have come over the way, treading our path to the tears, and the blood of the slaughtered.” That’s our history and if you can get in the mindset where you actually are seeing that then you can get to the last line where it says, “we will march on because we lift every voice and sing.” Not just people of color but say all that can see, that eyes can see and ears can hear, that this is a history that was affected by people but the brunt of that history was people of color. Why? Because we elevated ourselves to a level of being prideful that we were greater than anybody else and that’s how you get people relegated to these little areas saying well, “You don’t deserve to be part of this enlightenment.” And you aren’t taught to read and write. Why? Because it opens the doors but the whole point of the matter of what I’m trying to say is the history is right there but I don’t know how many people have actually sang that song or read the words but for every Thursday in Assembly we stood and now people sing the song and they are sitting and you say “What?” And that to me tells me right away, not only do you not know about the history, but you don’t know what is behind it and why we stand. And you see people saying, “Should I stand or should I sit?” And we sit among the sisters and brothers and say, “What? What happened?” Because we all stood because we knew it was part of our culture but now, like you referred to, something being glossed over. How do you gloss over “Lift Every Voice and Sing?” with conscience if you want to be part of the African American experience and to elevate people to a level that is honest and true to who they are as a people, as a culture, as a force to be reckoned with. Sorry y’all. I got…
Various Group Members: No, thank you so much. This is…. We’re not gonna shut you down. Just know that.